The struggles of Manchester United in recent years have not only been about results on the pitch but also about how successive coaches have managed – or mismanaged – the talents at their disposal. Under current manager Rúben Amorim, the issue seems to have deepened, with several fans questioning whether the Portuguese tactician truly understands the strengths of his players.
A coach at this level is not expected to teach professionals how to pass or chase the ball – they already know the fundamentals. Rather, the responsibility lies in helping players rediscover their form, confidence, and consistency when they struggle. Unfortunately, critics argue that Amorim has failed in this regard, especially in his handling of Marcus Rashford, Alejandro Garnacho, and André Onana.
Flick’s Approach vs. Amorim’s Missteps
Barcelona boss Hansi Flick offers a stark contrast. Before signing Marcus Rashford this summer, Flick had studied the forward extensively and was fully aware of his strengths, weaknesses, and preferred positions.
Ahead of Barcelona’s Champions League clash with Newcastle United, Flick reminded Rashford of his past record against the Magpies and promised to play him in his best role. The result? Rashford responded with a stunning brace, winning Man of the Match and sending a clear message that he thrives under a manager who trusts and understands him.
In comparison, United’s recent coaches — from Erik ten Hag to Amorim — have often been accused of playing key men out of position and discarding talent instead of building around it. Only Ole Gunnar Solskjær appeared to strike the right balance, respecting his players’ natural qualities and encouraging a freer, more attacking style of football, though his time at the club ended without silverware.
The Rashford Example
Rashford’s resurgence at Barcelona under Flick has reignited debates among United fans about how poorly he was handled at Old Trafford. If the English forward can rediscover his brilliance so quickly under a new coach, it raises the question: was the problem ever the player, or the way he was managed?
What Next for United?
Manchester United is a club built on identity, attacking football, and getting the best from its stars. But if Amorim insists on rigid tactics, questionable formations, and persisting with selections that push players away rather than bring out their best, then the club risks further decline.
Many supporters are already voicing the same concern: unless Amorim adapts quickly, United should not hesitate to make a change before irreparable damage is done to their “darling” team.
